Was going to try Jacob &Co last time is was in Toronto but I loved Hys so much the first time I was there I had to go back again so my list is
NYC: Strip House, Peter Lugers was an experience but not the best steak ever, however the bacon is amazing
Toronto: Hys
Jackson Hole, WY: Local Restaurant & Bar
Pittsburgh: Hyde Park - it's a chain but I believe there's only 5-7 locations
Las Vegas: STK in the Comsopoltian
Ft. Lauderdale: Shulas
I'm sure I'm forgetting some