reading through this thread had me feeling a little insecure until I came across your post and BrightonCorgi's post. I can understand some cigars feel heavier, have a giant knot, or might be lighter in weight than the others, but appearances can be quite deceiving. This is especially true if we are talking about specific brands like Sancho Panza. Some of the best Molinos I had were the ugliest.
If they are all plugged, get a perfect draw tool. It works wonders and has saved a lot of cigars from the trash. In this case, it might save thanksgiving dinner with the family.