85 is way too high for a dog rocket.
A cigar scoring above 90 has hit nearly all the marks, spot on draw and construction, complexity, great flavours, etc.
A cigar scoring bewteen 80-90 is a good cigar, nothing stellar, but still a good cigar. May miss a few points for having a fault or two; draw being a bit too tight, construction off, flavour but not much complexity, etc
A cigar with a score between 70-80 is average, no complexity, construction/draw/flavour is just ok. More than 2-3 faults.
A cigar with a score between 60-70 is sub-par. Many faults but still smokeable....barely. Pitchworthy.
A dog rocket has no redeeming features whatsoever. The only thing getting points... they managed to roll it with tobacco... maybe.