I've smoked stellar Edmundos. I've smoked poor Edmundos. The box that was the best, had really light and smooth wrappers. If I could have cloned the box, I would have. Those were sweet, light cocoa powder/sugar. Darker ones, more bitter chocolate cocoa powder/powdered sugar, but good, even though they looked like they were wrapped with brown tree bark. To me its a good cigar. I've had less luck with the DE personally, but haven't smoked as many.