CRW Review: Montecristo Especial No 1


Recommended Posts

Cigar Review: Montecristo Especiale No 1

Date: Nov 8 2010 12:30PM EST

Place: My back deck. A "warm" 9C but a bit breezy.

Drink Pairing: None, wanted to enjoy this on its' own.

Pre light observations:

Excellent construction: beautiful light brown wrapper// no hard or soft spots

Aroma// nice chocolaty smell & tobacco//

Cold draw - good to very good.

Before we get into the review. I've made a slight adjustment to the way I track things. Where commas separated my tasting notes or thoughts, I've now inserted "//" for separation. This is a bit wordy, but I've put a lot of pictures in as well. So, sit back, relax and enjoy.

First Third

The cigar lit easily// milk coffee// mild leather// milk coffee// good burn slightly askew// chocolate/tobacco mix// good creamy smoke// leather// burn starting to correct itself// light coffee taste// seems like a light smoke so far// but tastier than the Montecristo Open Eagle :cowpoop: which pleases me// great looking cigar// earthy aftertaste// slightly dry// coffee// ash broke off onto me a bit earlier than i expected// at least it part with a rich rich tobacco taste// some leather// faint hint of dry walnut// draw is good// nice earthy taste// almost dried berry taste// some pepper starting to emerge// richer leather taste// dried nut on the tongue// more pepper// richer earthier flavours// fresher taste emerged// hard to describe// almost citrusy// nice cocoa note with spice// earthy coffee flavour// draw is a bit tight afterall// feeling a bit lightheaded// its too nice outside to feel that way// earth & pepper taste// nice rich tasting draw very earthy// ash hasn't gotten more than 1/2 inch. I suspect the slight breeze might have something to do with it// rich tobacco & coffee taste// almost done 1st third// slight hint of dried fruit turned to leather// burn 90% perfect// more dried fruit// smoke getting creamier// taste of dry walnut on the palate// almost tanniny// rich tobacco// draw is good but still tight IMO// dry walnut// dry prppery// ash at 1inch holding strong// cigar is getting richer in its taste// spoke to soon ash takes tumble on next draw// very flaky and brittle ash// burn slightly askew// slightly stronger coffee flavour with leather finish// coffee bean and pepper// I now declare the 1st third over.

post-6763-1289273030.jpg

post-6763-1289273059.jpg

post-6763-1289273065.jpg

post-6763-1289273077.jpg

post-6763-1289273085.jpg

Second Third

The burn starts to correct itself// my next draw is peppery and earthy at the same time// so far this is kicking the MOE's sorry ass// another hint of citrus followed by a sharp tang of pepper// corrected burn// rich tobacco taste with dry finish// nice day but a bit chilly my Canon 20D feels icy to the touch// dried fruit with a nice citrus follow through// I'm impressed so far I'd say this is a

medium strength cigar// woodsy earthy flavour// light coffee again for a nice contrast// toasted tobacco with dry finish// ash back to 1/2 inch// smooth tobacoo flavour takes its time with lots of creamy smoke// I'm tempted to start burning leaves for warmth// near purfect burn the ash drops a lighter tobacco flavours gives way// mmm cocoa coffee mix :drool: // toasty tobacco again// some pepper on the palate// nuts and leather// stronger tobacco// from a burn aspect this is a very well behaved cigar minuse to two surprise ash breakaways// 3 very hard draws little smoke// might need a relight// some ammonia & draw tightens spoke too soon// nice creamy smoke and a trifecta of flavours: tobacco, leather & coffee bean! :drool: :drool: // dried nut// blustery looking ash possibly due to relight// nice tall blonde in tight Lululemon pants jogs by....oh and some more leather though muted..yes back to the cigar ;) // toasted tobacco// light cocoa// leather tobacco mix// getting chillier 2nd third almost done dont want to rush this though// dry walnut// dark gray ash past the 1/2 inch mark which means it will land on me soon// burn askew ill leave it for now// lighter tobacco taste with dry aftertones emerge// draw tightens again// tapped off the ash with one try//

post-6763-1289273092.jpg

post-6763-1289273119.jpg

post-6763-1289273123.jpg

post-6763-1289273127.jpg

post-6763-1289273132.jpg

Third Third

I had to relight again :tantrum: // light tobacco follows//draw still a bit tight// earthy// smoke volume picks up draw improves & light leather// ...lovely blonde crosses the street and lights up a cigarette.... :no: oh well// light coffee and nut// light coffee again// burn improves// hmmm nice vegetal taste like green bell pepper, very interesting// lots of smoke and that vegetal taste again!// idle burn seems to increase// toasted tobacco// light milk coffee re-emerges// ash bacvk to 1/2inch// leather// rich tobacco// out again!// relight brings back rich tobacco// i blame the weather this cigar has been excellent despite it// dried nut and burn good// earthy tastes smoke volume improves// sharp pepper some ammonia// coffee followed by vegetal richness wow// woa again// cant feel my fingers though but the cigar is delivering// toasted tobacco// coffee bean// peeled band off as i approach end of 3/3// medium leather taste// leather again and ash drops off into tray// wind picking up..// good creamy smoke// profile starts to return to light body// aftertastes are dry yet pleasant// lighht coffee// rich hit of tobacco// tobacco// cccccold// pepper// rich tobacco// good burn// dried walnut with power// mmm nutmeg just beautiful....not letting up// earthy tobacco// nicotine being felt finally or is thhat cold chills?// pepper and some ammonia// sun coming round// toasted tobacco// rich toasted tobacco// tobacco// good ash lots of smoke and leather// coffee grounds// past 3/3 and nearing nub// vegatal hints lots of smoke// leather// tobacco//

post-6763-1289273137.jpg

post-6763-1289273142.jpg

post-6763-1289273148.jpg

post-6763-1289273155.jpg

post-6763-1289273159.jpg

post-6763-1289273167.jpg

Total Smoking time: 95 minutes (and that felt rushed due to the cold under the right conditions, this would have kept me company for a solid 2 hours)

Final Thoughts

I am one happy camper. Every since I had my first Cohiba Lancero I fell in love with this shape: the Laguito No 1. I've had a Cuban Davidoff No 1, a NC Casa Fernandez Lancero, which was very good IMO and now having had the Montecristo Especial No 1 I've taken a small tour of this disappearing vitola. From my notes above, you can see that this cigar was a marathon of flavours. It completely wiped the bad/no taste from my mouth that the shameful Open Eagle left not too long ago. I would classify this as a medium bodied cigar with some light and strong tasting notes. The weather outside took a bit away from my enjoyment of this beauty in that I believe the wind and cold forced two re-lights of the cigar. Had I been smoking on a warm, windless summer night I'd bet that no re-lights would be necessary. This is a cigar to really sit back with. Despite the bad weather, it gave me 90 minutes of bliss. I feel I rushed through it at times just to ward off the frostbite in my fingers. :D. I bought six of these from the Czar to try out and I'm glad I did. These would be a box-worthy investment as they are tasty from foot to head. I pretty well nubbed this baby.

FINAL SCORE: 90.

I would have given it a 92/93. What prevented it from reaching a higher score was some bad draws at certain points and the re-lights. I've given the weather as a caveat on the relights but I suspect the draw was partially responsible for that too. If I smoke the next one in more hospitable conditions I'm sure the score will jump.

Thanks for taking the time to read this. I hope you enjoyed it.

Cheers,

Frank :cigar:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Great review, Frank. A nice change, no doubt, from the MOE.

Question - getting frost bite on your fingers, in a "warm" 9 Celsius?!?!?!!? Pansy. :blush::P

And for the review, I love the extra text, and your puff-by-puff account of things, I just don't know about the double //'s - just my observations. Got a little crazy for me to follow for a bit.

And your pictures are top notch - well done. Love the step-by-step on those; reminds me of an online cigar review place that does the same idea, but their pics aren't as sharp and nice, IMO.

Kudos.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Question - getting frost bite on your fingers, in a "warm" 9 Celsius?!?!?!!? Pansy. :o:P

It was 9C in the sun, I was in the shade.. a lot colder. Besides, I'm not ready to accept that winter is coming. I was in trackpants and a hoodie. :blush:

Thanks for the compliments. I'll experiment with the dialog flow in the next review(s). If its' nice tomorrow I may just dip into the humidor for something special.

Cheers,

Frank

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

Community Software by Invision Power Services, Inc.